news4global
  • Home
  • Bitcoin
  • Blockchain
  • Business
  • Latest news
  • Market
  • Regulation
  • VideosHot
    ये Coins कर सकते बर्बाद ‼️  Solana Bad news | 30 दिसंबर को बड़ी हलचल | Cryptocurrency | crypto news

    ये Coins कर सकते बर्बाद ‼️ Solana Bad news | 30 दिसंबर को बड़ी हलचल | Cryptocurrency | crypto news

    🔥 100X POTENTIAL? 🔥 LONG TERM BNB PRICE PREDICTION – Crypto News Today

    🔥 100X POTENTIAL? 🔥 LONG TERM BNB PRICE PREDICTION – Crypto News Today

    Last Chance to Buy Ada (Cardano) || Ada (Cardano) Price Prediction || Ada News Today || Ada Update

    Last Chance to Buy Ada (Cardano) || Ada (Cardano) Price Prediction || Ada News Today || Ada Update

    20/12/2022 Cryptocurrency Tamil news today | Shiba inu coin news | luna crypto news | Bitcoin Tamil

    20/12/2022 Cryptocurrency Tamil news today | Shiba inu coin news | luna crypto news | Bitcoin Tamil

    🚀Binance ने Cryptowalo को Goodnews दी ✅️🚀| Cryptocurrency | Shiba inu news today

    🚀Binance ने Cryptowalo को Goodnews दी ✅️🚀| Cryptocurrency | Shiba inu news today

    Emergency ♦️ बंद हो गया था Binance ⚠️ | Crypto News Today | Cryptocurrency | Bitcoin

    Emergency ♦️ बंद हो गया था Binance ⚠️ | Crypto News Today | Cryptocurrency | Bitcoin

    Top 3 Crypto Binance Upcoming Listing | top cryptocurrency to invest in 2023 | Crypto news today |

    Top 3 Crypto Binance Upcoming Listing | top cryptocurrency to invest in 2023 | Crypto news today |

    ELON MUSK’S HUGE WARNING! 🚨 CRYPTO NEWS TODAY 🔥 CRYPTOCURRENCY NEWS LATEST! 🔥 BITCOIN NEWS TODAY

    ELON MUSK’S HUGE WARNING! 🚨 CRYPTO NEWS TODAY 🔥 CRYPTOCURRENCY NEWS LATEST! 🔥 BITCOIN NEWS TODAY

    IIF CEO Adams on Banking Risks, Cryptocurrency Regulation

    IIF CEO Adams on Banking Risks, Cryptocurrency Regulation

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Bitcoin
  • Blockchain
  • Business
  • Latest news
  • Market
  • Regulation
  • VideosHot
    ये Coins कर सकते बर्बाद ‼️  Solana Bad news | 30 दिसंबर को बड़ी हलचल | Cryptocurrency | crypto news

    ये Coins कर सकते बर्बाद ‼️ Solana Bad news | 30 दिसंबर को बड़ी हलचल | Cryptocurrency | crypto news

    🔥 100X POTENTIAL? 🔥 LONG TERM BNB PRICE PREDICTION – Crypto News Today

    🔥 100X POTENTIAL? 🔥 LONG TERM BNB PRICE PREDICTION – Crypto News Today

    Last Chance to Buy Ada (Cardano) || Ada (Cardano) Price Prediction || Ada News Today || Ada Update

    Last Chance to Buy Ada (Cardano) || Ada (Cardano) Price Prediction || Ada News Today || Ada Update

    20/12/2022 Cryptocurrency Tamil news today | Shiba inu coin news | luna crypto news | Bitcoin Tamil

    20/12/2022 Cryptocurrency Tamil news today | Shiba inu coin news | luna crypto news | Bitcoin Tamil

    🚀Binance ने Cryptowalo को Goodnews दी ✅️🚀| Cryptocurrency | Shiba inu news today

    🚀Binance ने Cryptowalo को Goodnews दी ✅️🚀| Cryptocurrency | Shiba inu news today

    Emergency ♦️ बंद हो गया था Binance ⚠️ | Crypto News Today | Cryptocurrency | Bitcoin

    Emergency ♦️ बंद हो गया था Binance ⚠️ | Crypto News Today | Cryptocurrency | Bitcoin

    Top 3 Crypto Binance Upcoming Listing | top cryptocurrency to invest in 2023 | Crypto news today |

    Top 3 Crypto Binance Upcoming Listing | top cryptocurrency to invest in 2023 | Crypto news today |

    ELON MUSK’S HUGE WARNING! 🚨 CRYPTO NEWS TODAY 🔥 CRYPTOCURRENCY NEWS LATEST! 🔥 BITCOIN NEWS TODAY

    ELON MUSK’S HUGE WARNING! 🚨 CRYPTO NEWS TODAY 🔥 CRYPTOCURRENCY NEWS LATEST! 🔥 BITCOIN NEWS TODAY

    IIF CEO Adams on Banking Risks, Cryptocurrency Regulation

    IIF CEO Adams on Banking Risks, Cryptocurrency Regulation

No Result
View All Result
news4global
No Result
View All Result
Home Blockchain

Is Crypto a Security or Commodity? Look to Congress’ Ethics Rules

July 14, 2022
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0
Is Crypto a Security or Commodity? Look to Congress’ Ethics Rules
189
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Related articles

Yoda Labs Weekly Digest: January 19 – 25 – BSC NEWS

Yoda Labs Weekly Digest: January 19 – 25 – BSC NEWS

January 28, 2023
Cryptocurrency Price Today: Popular Coins Like Bitcoin, Ethereum Reported Gains As Threshold Emerged As Biggest Loser

Cryptocurrency Price Today: Popular Coins Like Bitcoin, Ethereum Reported Gains As Threshold Emerged As Biggest Loser

January 28, 2023

The Responsible Financial Innovation Act introduced on Jun 7, 2022 includes a comprehensive regulatory framework for digital assets and seeks to provide clarity in how digital assets, such as cryptocurrencies, are treated under US securities law. The lynchpin of the bill is the codification of the US Supreme Court’s decades-old standard for determining when a financial offering is a “security,” i.e., the Howey test.

If cryptocurrency is a “security,” then crypto-companies issuing them must comply with Securities and Exchange Commission rules for registration and reporting—failure to do so can lead to significant penalties, such as the $100 million SEC fine. issued by the SEC in 2021.

However, many in the industry believe that cryptocurrencies act more like commodities than securities and would prefer them to be treated as such, subject to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s rules. The “security” vs. “commodity” debate has many practical implications for the cryptocurrency industry, as well as consumers, and is already heating up in Washington.

But the RFIA, introduced June 7 by Sens. Cynthia Lummis (R-Wy.) and Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.), is not the first time the federal government has tried to classify cryptocurrency. In fact, the ethics bodies that interpret the very rules that govern a federal official’s personal financial dealings—the Ethics in Government Act and the Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge Act (STOCK Act)—have already weighed in on the “security” vs. “commodity” debate.

Advocates and attorneys parsing the RFIA will also want to understand the contours of these ethics laws before they step into the fray because these rules are the ones that govern a federal official’s own wallet.

Congress and the STOCK Act

The STOCK Act requires members of Congress and certain staff to report transactions related to specified assets within 45 days. Specifically, transactions over $1,000 for “stocks, bonds, commodities futures, and other forms of securities” must be publicly reported.

Both House and Senate guidance explicitly consider cryptocurrencies as covered, however, only the House guidance identifies the category under which cryptocurrencies fall: “other forms of security.” Although the House guidance is limited in applicability to U.S. representatives and certain House staff, high-profile examples where members of Congress have reported cryptocurrency transactions (or failed to) may be creating new norms.

For example, Rep. Madison Cawthorn (R-N.C.) recently filed such a report, albeit late, for purchases and sales of a “meme-coin” cryptocurrency. By filing the reports, Cawthorn presumably concedes that the cryptocurrency is a type of other security required to be reported under the STOCK Act.

The Senate Select Committee on Ethics has not publicly opined about what category of asset cryptocurrency falls under, although the Senate’s practice appears to align with that of the House. For example, the purchase of Bitcoin by a senator has been reported under the STOCK Act, indicating that Senate Ethics treats all cryptocurrencies as covered transactions.

At least at the congressional level, there appears to be consensus that cryptocurrencies, even Bitcoin, are a type of security when they are bought and sold by a member of Congress. But does the executive branch agree?

OGE and the Fed

Compared to Congress, the executive branch has taken a more nuanced approach to the taxonomy of cryptocurrency. Guidance from the Office of Government Ethics in 2018 answered the question of what type of asset cryptocurrency is under the STOCK Act with a very lawyerly answer—it depends.

The guidance stated that it is not “clear under the EIGA whether particular virtual currencies may or may not qualify as one of the investment terms specified in the [STOCK Act] for transaction reporting. The term with the most likely application is ‘other forms of securities.’ However, while the term ‘securities’ appears in the EIGA, it is not therein defined.”

Notably, the OGE stated that Bitcoin, which “the CFTC has determined it to be a commodity,” need not be reported. Rather than attempting to fit all cryptocurrencies into a category, the OGE advises employees who may be “uncertain whether a particular virtual currency holding is a security” to report cryptocurrency transactions of more than $1,000.

In February 2022, the Federal Reserve Board announced regulations that ban senior officials from owning or trading certain assets, one of which is “cryptocurrency.” Unlike the other examples, the Federal Reserve separately defines cryptocurrency, and does so without categorizing it as a security or commodity. “Cryptocurrency” means “a digital asset implemented using cryptographic techniques designed to work as a medium of exchange.”

As important as that definition is, more critical is what “cryptocurrency” is not—it is neither a security nor a commodity, both of which are separately defined. Although there is room under those definitions for certain digital assets be both a “cryptocurrency” and a “security,” these rules went into effect July 1, so we will see how they are honored in the breach.

Where Do We Go From Here?

Those thinking about policy in the digital asset, cryptocurrency, and web3 industries would be well served to understand the rules that public officials already are subject to when handling digital assets of their own.

The RFIA or other bills may frame the terms of debate, but throughout the legislative and regulatory processes, government officials will simultaneously be grappling with how to treat cryptocurrencies in their own wallets and will be interacting with these ethics rules and interpretations already in place.

This article does not necessarily reflect the opinion of The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc., the publisher of Bloomberg Law and Bloomberg Tax, or its owners.

Write for Us: Author Guidelines

Author Information

William A. Powers is a partner in Nossaman LLP’s Washington, D.C., office, where he advises PACs, nonprofits, and companies on compliance with lobbying, ethics, and campaign finance rules. He also helps his clients, including those in the tech, crypto, and financial services industries, navigate the rules related to all aspects of engaging with government officials and candidates.

Share76Tweet47

Related Posts

Yoda Labs Weekly Digest: January 19 – 25 – BSC NEWS

Yoda Labs Weekly Digest: January 19 – 25 – BSC NEWS

by admin
January 28, 2023
0

Yoda Labs Weekly Digest: January 19 - 25  BSC NEWS

Cryptocurrency Price Today: Popular Coins Like Bitcoin, Ethereum Reported Gains As Threshold Emerged As Biggest Loser

Cryptocurrency Price Today: Popular Coins Like Bitcoin, Ethereum Reported Gains As Threshold Emerged As Biggest Loser

by admin
January 28, 2023
0

Bitcoin (BTC) and Ethereum (ETH) — two of the most valued crypto coins — managed to rise above the $23,000...

New Cryptocurrency Unlikely To Help Russia And Iran Evade Sanctions

New Cryptocurrency Unlikely To Help Russia And Iran Evade Sanctions

by admin
January 27, 2023
0

TEHRAN, IRAN - Russian President Vladimir Putin (L) meets with Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi (R) ... in Tehran ahead of...

Paradigm Policy Council to Tackle the Crypto Challenges: Policy Director By CoinEdition

UK’s FCA hints at why its given only 15% of crypto firms the regulatory nod By Cointelegraph

by admin
January 27, 2023
0

Despite the plans to turn the region into a bustling crypto hub, the United Kingdom’s financial watchdog says it has...

Instant Payments, Future of Crypto, Cross-Border Payments and Innovation at the Forefront

Instant Payments, Future of Crypto, Cross-Border Payments and Innovation at the Forefront

by admin
January 26, 2023
0

Secure Technology AllianceEvent to include prominent speakers representing top global payments organizationsREDWOOD CITY, Calif., Jan. 26, 2023 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) --...

Load More
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest

Bitcoin Is ‘Definitely Not a Fraud,’ CEO of Mobile-Only Bank Revolut Says

March 2, 2022

Bitcoin’s Main Rival Ethereum Hits A Fresh Record High: $425.55

March 3, 2022
How online shopping has changed over the last 30 years | National

How online shopping has changed over the last 30 years | National

April 6, 2022
Protocon Announces ‘Contract Model’, an Alternative

Protocon Announces ‘Contract Model’, an Alternative

April 6, 2022

US Commodities Regulator Beefs Up Bitcoin Futures Review

0

Bitcoin Hits 2018 Low as Concerns Mount on Regulation, Viability

0

India: Bitcoin Prices Drop As Media Misinterprets Gov’s Regulation Speech

0

Bitcoin’s Main Rival Ethereum Hits A Fresh Record High: $425.55

0
Yoda Labs Weekly Digest: January 19 – 25 – BSC NEWS

Yoda Labs Weekly Digest: January 19 – 25 – BSC NEWS

January 28, 2023
Bitcoin (BTC) Price Prediction 2025-2030: Will BTC’s sideways market continue

Bitcoin (BTC) Price Prediction 2025-2030: Will BTC’s sideways market continue

January 28, 2023
State crypto commission offers policy recommendations | State news

State crypto commission offers policy recommendations | State news

January 28, 2023
US Allows Use Of NFTs For Fundraising Activities, ReelStar Rolls Out NFT Creation Zone

Elon Musk Wants McDonald’s to Accept Dogecoin; Amazon to Launch NFT Initiative

January 28, 2023

Latest News

Yoda Labs Weekly Digest: January 19 – 25 – BSC NEWS

Yoda Labs Weekly Digest: January 19 – 25 – BSC NEWS

January 28, 2023
Bitcoin (BTC) Price Prediction 2025-2030: Will BTC’s sideways market continue

Bitcoin (BTC) Price Prediction 2025-2030: Will BTC’s sideways market continue

January 28, 2023

Categories

Site Navigation

  • Home
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and services
  • Home
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and services

© 2022 Designed by news4global

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Bitcoin
  • Blockchain
  • Business
  • Latest news
  • Market
  • Regulation
  • Videos

© 2022 Designed by news4global